Neo Sindarin - Reconstruction of the "to be" verb
Reconstruction of the "to be" verb
This is extremely speculative and not at all authoritative. If you want a conservative and source-based paradigm, walk away now! This is akin to my personal notes.
Based on Salo's analysis of the "to be" verb, and based on the fact that a lot of information has been disclosed since the publication of his book, I've decided to attempt a reconstruction myself.
David Salo treated na- as a derived A-stem verb. Other Neo-Sindarin analysts treat it instead as a monosyllabic basic verb, derived directly from the primitive root √NA ("be, exist"). The elephant in the room is that no attested basic verbs end in vowels. So a large portion of the content below include some speculative assumptions.
Present tense
This reconstruction treats the copular verb na- as an irregular monosyllabic verb descended from Primitive Eldarin √NĀ, rather than as an ordinary derived A-stem. The goal is an internally consistent and phonologically plausible Neo-Sindarin conjugation, drawing on Tolkien's attested pronominal elements, the Sindarin verbal suffixes, and documented historical sound changes.
None of the complete Sindarin copular forms proposed below is directly attested in Tolkien's writings. The reconstructions therefore remain hypothetical, even where their individual components and phonological developments are supported.
Historical and phonological foundations
The primitive root √NĀ, "be (the same as another), exist", occurs in Tolkien's linguistic writings, including PE17/93, PE22/147 and VT49/27–31.
Sources:
The principal sound changes are:
| Development | Reference |
|---|---|
| Primitive final short i → e | PE19/100 |
| Loss of final short vowels | PE18/100; PE19/105 |
| Long ā → ǭ | PE18/96; PE19/91 |
| ǭ → au | PE18/96 |
| Postvocalic k → g | Sindarin phonology |
| Postvocalic d → ð | PE22/31–32 |
The developmental sequences below are proposed phonological models. Some intermediate steps and their precise historical ordering remain uncertain, particularly because Tolkien revised the phonological history of Sindarin repeatedly.
Third-person singular: naw — "he/she/it is"
Primitive Eldarin nā- is taken as the verbal stem. As with many Sindarin verbs, the uninflected present serves as the third-person singular. The inherited long vowel follows its normal historical development:
✶nā → OS nǭ → S nau → naw
The final spelling -aw represents the diphthong au in word-final position. This approach does not require extending the late basic-verb vowel-lengthening rule (car- → câr) to an otherwise unattested class of monosyllabic vowel-final basic verbs.
Status: Plausibly derived Neo-Sindarin reconstruction. The assumption that primitive nā itself served as the unsuffixed present form remains hypothetical.
First-person singular: naun — "I am"
The first-person singular pronoun ✶ni, "I, me", is attested in VT49/50, 52 and elsewhere. Assuming the pronoun became a verbal suffix in Primitive Eldarin:
✶nā + ✶ni → ✶nāni
✶nāni → nāne → nān → nǭn → naun
The changes are:
- Final short -i becomes -e.
- Final short -e disappears.
- Long ā develops into ǭ.
- ǭ develops into au.
This also explains why the short Sindarin first-person suffix -n produces the same result: the full primitive pronoun -ni has lost its final vowel. The proposed form therefore converges with the simpler formation:
✶nā-n → ✶nān → naun
Status: Plausibly derived Neo-Sindarin reconstruction. The pronoun ni is attested, but the primitive conjugation nāni is hypothetical.
Source: Eldamo: ✶ni, VT49/50, 52.
First-person plural exclusive: nauf — "we are, excluding you"
The Primitive Elvish pronoun ✶me, "we (exclusive)", is attested in VT49/50, 52. Tolkien's 1969 Sindarin verbal material contains the exclusive suffix -f /v/, as in athof (PE22/167), and Paul Strack suggests that this ending represents a historical development of earlier -m(e).
However, combining nā- and -me in Primitive Eldarin creates a phonological difficulty:
✶nāme → nām → nǭm → naum → nauv → naw
The final v disappears after au, following the development discussed by Tolkien in WJ/414. To preserve a productive first-person exclusive distinction, the proposed paradigm therefore adopts late morphological suffixation. The copular stem and the exclusive ending develop independently, and the completed form is then constructed:
✶nā → S naw
✶-me ⇝ S -f /v/
naw + -f → nauf
The spelling au replaces final aw before the added consonant.
Status: Hypothetical late Neo-Sindarin morphological formation, supported by an attested Sindarin pronominal ending. It is not the regular uninterrupted phonological outcome of primitive nāme.
Sources:
- Eldamo: ✶me
- Eldamo: Subject suffixes, PE22/167
- Loss of final v after au, WJ/414
First-person plural inclusive: naub — "we are, including you"
The inclusive first-person plural ending -b occurs in Tolkien's 1969 Sindarin material, illustrated by athab (PE22/167). Strack tentatively derives this from an older -p(e), possibly originating in -kwe, but the exact etymology remains uncertain.
This reconstruction does not require establishing that full primitive derivation. It relies instead on Tolkien's attested late Sindarin suffix, attached to the independently developed copular stem:
✶nā → S naw
naw + -b → naub
As in nauf, aw is written au when followed by a consonant.
Status: Hypothetical late Neo-Sindarin morphological formation based on the attested 1969 inclusive verbal suffix. The primitive origin of -b remains uncertain.
Source: Eldamo: Subject suffixes, PE22/167.
Second-person singular familiar: naug — "thou art"
The primitive familiar second-person pronoun ✶ki is attested in VT49/50, 52. The Sindarin familiar second-person verbal ending -g is documented in Tolkien's 1962 paradigm (PE17/132), including the form galog. We reconstruct an early attachment of the primitive pronoun:
✶nā + ✶ki → ✶nāki
✶nāki → nāke → nāk → nǭk → nauk → naug
The changes are:
- Final -i → -e.
- Final short -e disappears.
- Long ā → ǭ.
- ǭ → au.
- Postvocalic k → g.
An alternative primitive formation with the pronoun already reduced to -k yields the same result:
✶nāk → nǭk → nauk → naug
Status: Plausibly derived Neo-Sindarin reconstruction. Both the primitive familiar pronoun and the later Sindarin ending are attested, although the complete copular conjugation is not.
Sources:
- Eldamo: ✶ki, VT49/50, 52
- Eldamo: Sindarin subject suffixes, PE17/132
Second-person singular polite: naul — "you are"
The primitive polite second-person pronoun ✶le occurs in VT49/50, 52. Tolkien's 1969 Sindarin verbal material employs the polite singular suffix -l, probably influenced by Quenya according to Strack. Two reconstructions are possible, and both produce the same surface form:
Early attachment:
✶nāle → nāl → nǭl → naul
Late attachment:
✶nā → S naw
naw + -l → naul
The early attachment involves loss of final -e, followed by ā → ǭ → au. Given Strack's suggestion of Quenya influence on the later Sindarin polite pronoun, late attachment may offer the more plausible morphological history.
Status: Plausibly derived Neo-Sindarin reconstruction, supported by an attested primitive pronoun and a later Sindarin verbal suffix.
Source: Eldamo: ✶le, VT49/50–52; PE22/167.
Second-person singular archaic: naudh — "you are"
The earlier Sindarin polite pronoun †de, "thee/you", occurs in PE17/26; Tolkien subsequently replaced it with le in the relevant notes. The 1962 Sindarin paradigm uses polite verbal -ð, written -dh. Strack suggests this might descend from an earlier -d(e) and tentatively associates it with Doriathrin usage. Assuming an earlier attachable form -de, we reconstruct:
✶nāde → nāðe → nāð → nǭð → nauð → naudh
The principal developments are:
- Postvocalic d → ð.
- Loss of final short -e.
- Long ā → ǭ.
- ǭ → au.
In ordinary Sindarin spelling, nauð is written naudh. For this paradigm, naudh is retained as an archaic or dialectal alternative to naul.
Status: Plausibly derived Neo-Sindarin reconstruction, with a hypothetical early attachment. Its identification as specifically Doriathrin is tentative.
Sources:
- Eldamo: †de, PE17/26
- Eldamo: Subject suffixes, PE17/132
Second-person plural familiar: naugir — "you are"
The 1962 Sindarin paradigm provides the second-person plural familiar suffix -gir, corresponding to singular -g. Strack observes that second-person plural endings commonly consist of the corresponding singular ending plus -ir. The proposed plural formation is therefore:
naug + -ir → naugir
This is treated as suffixation within the developed Sindarin verbal system, not as an inherited Primitive Eldarin conjugation.
Status: Hypothetical Neo-Sindarin morphological formation supported by the attested Sindarin ending -gir.
Source: Eldamo: Subject suffixes, PE17/132.
Second-person plural polite: naulir — "you are"
The proposed singular polite form is naul, using Tolkien's later Sindarin suffix -l. Following the general second-person plural pattern, the plural is formed analogically:
naul + -ir → naulir
Unlike familiar -gir and archaic polite -dhir, a late Sindarin plural polite suffix -lir is not established by Tolkien's surviving 1969 material. The form is therefore an extrapolation from the productive second-person plural pattern rather than a directly supported conjugation.
Status: Analogical Neo-Sindarin reconstruction; less securely supported than naugir or naudhir.
Source: Eldamo: Subject suffixes, comparing PE17/132 and PE22/167.
Second-person plural archaic: naudhir — "you are"
Tolkien's 1962 paradigm provides the second-person plural polite suffix -ðir, corresponding to singular -ð. Applying this established ending to the proposed archaic singular form:
naudh + -ir → naudhir
This preserves the same relationship between singular and plural found in Tolkien's earlier Sindarin pronominal system.
Status: Hypothetical Neo-Sindarin morphological formation using an attested 1962 suffix. Its specifically Doriathrin or archaic interpretation remains tentative.
Source: Eldamo: Subject suffixes, PE17/132.
Third-person plural: nar — "they are"
Sindarin uses the plural agreement suffix -r for the third-person plural. Unlike the first and second persons, this ending is not necessarily pronominal in origin: it marks plural agreement and can also express "they" when no independent subject is present.
The ordinary inflection of Sindarin basic verbs demonstrates that plural forms need not derive directly from their uninflected singular surface forms, for example câr → cerir. However, nā- is unusual because its primitive stem ends in a long vowel rather than a consonant.
Helge Fauskanger discusses vowel-final verbal stems whose third-person plural is formed by adding -r after the stem vowel has shortened. Strack also considers the possibility that plural -r was added comparatively late. Adopting this approach, we propose a shortened inflectional stem:
✶nā- ⇝ *na-
*na- + -r → nar
This form is preferred over the alternative naur, which would arise from adding -r directly to the fully developed naw. The crucial assumption is that the copula acquired a shortened plural inflectional stem, by analogy with vowel-final verbs. Such a stem is not independently attested.
Status: Analogical Neo-Sindarin reconstruction, not an established phonological outcome of primitive nā-r.
Sources:
- Eldamo: Sindarin verb inflections, especially third-person plurality
- Ardalambion: Reconstructing the Sindarin Verb System
Summary
| Person | Present tense |
|---|---|
| First singular | naun |
| First plural exclusive | nauf |
| First plural inclusive | naub |
| Second singular familiar | naug |
| Second singular polite | naul |
| Second singular archaic | naudh |
| Second plural familiar | naugir |
| Second plural polite | naulir |
| Second plural archaic | naudhir |
| Third singular | naw |
| Third plural | nar |
These forms constitute a provisional Neo-Sindarin paradigm. They are not presented as an attested or definitive reconstruction of Tolkien's Sindarin. The system deliberately combines inherited phonological developments with later morphological suffixation and analogy. This is compatible with a productive irregular copula, provided each formation is identified accurately and the resulting paradigm is tested for phonological, morphological and syntactic consistency.
Past tense
Historical foundations
The past tense of the copular verb na- is reconstructed from Common Eldarin nē, an independent past-tense element meaning "was". Tolkien discusses this element in VT49/30–31 and PE22/96, explaining that it could function as a past-tense base as well as a temporal expression meaning "ago".
It underwent the regular Sindarin development of long ē into ī:
CE. nē → S. nî
Paul Strack independently proposed Neo-Sindarin nî ("was") and nîr ("were") in 2018.
The following paradigm extends nî through the established Sindarin pronominal suffixes, drawing primarily upon Tolkien's paradigms in PE17/132 and PE22/167. The inflections are formed within the Sindarin verbal system rather than being treated as inherited Common Eldarin subject-inflected forms.
All the complete conjugations remain Neo-Sindarin reconstructions, not attested Tolkienian forms.
First-person singular: nîn — "I was"
nî + -n → nîn
The first-person singular suffix -n is consistently documented throughout Tolkien's later Sindarin verbal paradigms (PE17/132; PE22/167).
The form can also be supported phonologically by a hypothetical earlier combination with primitive ni ("I"):
nēni → nēne → nīne → nīn
The proposed result is nîn, following Sindarin orthography for a long vowel in a stressed monosyllable.
First-person plural exclusive: nîf — "we were, excluding the listener"
nî + -f → nîf
The first-person plural exclusive suffix -f /v/ occurs in Tolkien's 1969 Sindarin material (PE22/167), exemplified by athof.
Strack suggests that this ending derives from primitive -m(e), associated with the exclusive pronoun me.
A hypothetical inherited formation would also yield the proposed form:
nēme → nēm → nīm → nīv
The resulting final /v/ is written f in Sindarin.
Thus, nîf is supported by both the established later suffix and a plausible historical phonological development.
First-person plural inclusive: nîb — "we were, including the listener"
nî + -b → nîb
The suffix -b is documented in Tolkien's 1969 Sindarin material (PE22/167), notably in athab ("we will", inclusive).
Its precise primitive origin remains uncertain. Strack tentatively derives it from an earlier -p(e), potentially connected with -kwe.
The reconstruction therefore uses the established Sindarin suffix directly, without requiring a hypothetical Primitive Eldarin conjugation.
Second-person singular familiar: nîg — "thou wast"
nî + -g → nîg
The familiar second-person singular suffix -g is documented in PE17/132, including Tolkien's conjugated form galog.
Its probable origin is the primitive second-person pronoun ki ("thou"), recorded in VT49/50, 52. The development from k to g is consistent with Sindarin postvocalic voicing.
A hypothetical earlier formation nēki provides a corresponding phonological explanation:
nēki → nēke → nīke → nīk → nīg
Second-person singular polite: nîl — "you were"
nî + -l → nîl
The polite second-person singular suffix -l occurs in Tolkien's 1969 Sindarin paradigm (PE22/167).
Strack connects it with the polite pronoun le, probably adopted into Sindarin usage through Quenya influence.
An earlier hypothetical combination nēle could yield the same result:
nēle → nēl → nīl
However, late suffixation is preferred as the morphological explanation, given the proposed borrowing history of -l.
Second-person singular archaic: nîdh — "you were"
nî + -dh → nîdh
Tolkien's 1962 Sindarin paradigm (PE17/132) uses the polite second-person suffix -ð, written -dh.
Strack suggests that this form derives from an older -d(e), associated with the pronoun de ("thee/you") in PE17/26. He tentatively identifies the ending with older or Doriathrin usage.
A hypothetical historical formation would develop as follows:
nēde → nēðe → nīðe → nīð
The final form is written nîdh.
For this paradigm, it is retained as an archaic or dialectal alternative to nîl, without asserting that Tolkien attested the copular form in Doriathrin.
Second-person plural familiar: nígir — "you were"
nî + -gir → nígir
The familiar second-person plural suffix -gir is documented in PE17/132. It corresponds to singular -g, extended by the plural element -ir.
Accordingly, the form may also be analysed as:
nîg + -ir → nígir
The long vowel is written with an acute accent in the resulting polysyllabic form, assuming its quantity is preserved.
Second-person plural polite: nílir — "you were"
nî + -lir → nílir
This form extends the later polite singular suffix -l through the second-person plural element -ir:
nîl + -ir → nílir
Although the singular suffix -l is supported by PE22/167, the complete polite plural suffix -lir is not directly established in Tolkien's surviving Sindarin paradigm.
The form is therefore an analogical Neo-Sindarin reconstruction, designed to preserve the singular–plural distinction within the later polite system.
Second-person plural archaic: nídhir — "you were"
nî + -dhir → nídhir
Tolkien's 1962 paradigm (PE17/132) documents the polite second-person plural suffix -ðir, corresponding to singular -ð.
It can be analysed as:
nîdh + -ir → nídhir
This form is retained as the plural counterpart of archaic or dialectal nîdh.
The historical suffix is attested, although the complete copular conjugation remains reconstructed.
Third-person singular: nî — "he/she/it was"
CE. nē → S. nî
The third-person singular is represented by the uninflected past stem, consistent with Sindarin verbal morphology.
The primitive element nē was explicitly described by Tolkien as an independent past form meaning "was" (VT49/30–31; PE22/96).
Its long ē regularly developed into Sindarin ī, yielding the proposed monosyllabic nî.
Unlike the personal conjugations above, this form requires no additional pronominal suffix.
Third-person plural: nîr — "they were"
nî + -r → nîr
The suffix -r is the regular Sindarin third-person plural agreement marker, documented in PE17/132.
Its origins are supported by PE22/93–94, where Tolkien identifies -r/-l as Common Eldarin plural subject markers.
The suffix indicates plural agreement rather than deriving from an independent pronoun meaning "they".
Paul Strack independently proposes nîr as the Neo-Sindarin plural counterpart of nî.
Summary
| Person | Past tense |
|---|---|
| First singular | nîn |
| First plural exclusive | nîf |
| First plural inclusive | nîb |
| Second singular familiar | nîg |
| Second singular polite | nîl |
| Second singular archaic | nîdh |
| Second plural familiar | nígir |
| Second plural polite | nílir |
| Second plural archaic | nídhir |
| Third singular | nî |
| Third plural | nîr |
The paradigm assumes that the inherited long vowel remains long when the personal suffixes are added. Its spelling follows the Sindarin convention of using circumflexes in stressed monosyllables and acute accents in polysyllables.
While nî and nîr have independent precedent in Strack's Neo-Sindarin proposals, the complete personal paradigm is a further reconstruction. In particular, nílir involves analogical extension of the later polite suffix, and the use of nîdh and nídhir as archaic alternatives remains tentative.
Principal sources
- Tolkien, Vinyar Tengwar 49, pp. 27–31 — Common Eldarin nē and its role in the past tense
- Tolkien, Parma Eldalamberon 22, pp. 93–96 — Common Eldarin verbal structure and past-tense morphology
- Tolkien, Parma Eldalamberon 17, p. 132 — Sindarin pronominal suffixes
- Tolkien, Parma Eldalamberon 22, p. 167 — Later Sindarin pronominal suffixes
- Tolkien, The Lord of the Rings, Appendix E — Sindarin orthographic conventions
- Eldamo: Subject suffixes
- Eldamo: Verb inflections
- Eldamo: Long ē and ō becoming ī and ū
- Eldamo: Neo-Sindarin nî
Future tense
Historical foundations
The future tense of the copular verb na- is reconstructed from Primitive Eldarin ✶nā- ("to be") and the Old Noldorin future suffix -thā, described by Tolkien in PE22/96–97.
In that account, the future was normally formed by adding -thā to the aorist stem. Tolkien suggested that the suffix originated in a temporal element meaning "then, next", associated with a pronominal stem pointing forwards in time.
This offers a possible basis for constructing a future tense of the copula without borrowing the distinct future formations employed in Quenya or Telerin.
However, Tolkien did not attest the proposed combination ✶nāthā, so the complete formation remains hypothetical.
Reconstruction of the future stem
The primitive copular stem is taken to preserve its inherited long ā when the future suffix is attached:
nā- + -tʰā → nātʰā
Applying the documented Sindarin sound changes gives the following proposed development:
nātʰā → nātʰa
→ nāθa
→ nǭθa
→ nauθa
→ noθa
The steps are:
- Final long-vowel shortening: Primitive final -ā becomes short -a in Old Sindarin, yielding nātʰa.
- Spirantisation: Aspirated tʰ becomes voiceless θ, yielding nāθa.
- Development of long ā: The stem vowel ā becomes ǭ, yielding nǭθa.
- Diphthongisation: ǭ becomes au, yielding nauθa.
- Reduction in polysyllables: au becomes o, yielding noθa.
In Sindarin orthography, θ is written th, giving the proposed future form:
notha = "will be"
The preservation of final -a is morphological rather than the expected result of unrestricted sound development. Sindarin future verbs characteristically retain this vowel, as demonstrated by Tolkien's anglennatha and estathar (SD/129). Paul Strack suggests that the vowel survived because it had become an integral part of the verbal inflection.
This reconstruction also avoids the collision with Tolkien's independently attested Sindarin natha- ("to bring help to, save, rescue"), recorded in PE22/166.
Phonological references:
- Old Sindarin shortening of final long vowels
- Aspirated stops becoming voiceless spirants
- Long ā becoming ǭ
- ǭ becoming au
- au becoming o in polysyllables
- Sindarin verbal inflections
Formation of personal conjugations
The reconstructed future stem is notha-. Its personal conjugations are formed by applying the Sindarin pronominal suffixes described in PE17/132 and PE22/167.
A characteristic feature of Sindarin future conjugation is the alternation of the final vowel a/o.
Where the historical long vowel -ā- was preserved before certain personal endings, it could undergo the regular development ā → ǭ → au → o. The vowel normally remains a in the uninflected third-person singular, before the plural agreement ending -r, and in some formations whose pronominal endings historically began with consonant clusters.
The following conjugations apply that pattern to the proposed future stem.
First-person singular: nothon — "I will be"
notha- + -n → nothon
The first-person singular ending -n is attested throughout Tolkien's Sindarin pronominal paradigms.
Before this ending, the final vowel of a future stem ordinarily appears as o. Compare the attested linnathon ("I will sing", LotR, Book II, Chapter 8) and Tolkien's cawathon (PE22/152).
The proposed future copula therefore becomes nothon rather than nothan.
Status: Plausibly reconstructed Neo-Sindarin form, employing an attested personal ending and established future-tense vowel alternation.
First-person plural exclusive: nothof — "we will be, excluding the listener"
notha- + -f → nothof
The exclusive first-person plural ending -f /v/ is attested in Tolkien's 1969 Sindarin material, particularly athof ("yes, we will", exclusive), PE22/167.
The vowel a becomes o before the ending, matching Tolkien's athof.
The resulting nothof preserves the distinction between exclusive and inclusive first-person plural forms established in our present and past reconstructions.
Status: Plausibly reconstructed Neo-Sindarin form, closely supported by the attested formation athof.
First-person plural inclusive: nothab — "we will be, including the listener"
notha- + -b → nothab
The inclusive first-person plural ending -b occurs in Tolkien's athab ("yes, we will", inclusive), PE22/167.
Unlike athof, this form preserves a before the pronominal ending.
Strack suggests that the difference reflects the historical origin of -b in a consonant cluster, possibly involving -kw(e), which caused the preceding long vowel to shorten before developing into o.
Following the attested contrast athof : athab, the proposed copula forms nothof : nothab.
Status: Plausibly reconstructed Neo-Sindarin form, with direct support for its vowel pattern in PE22/167.
Second-person singular familiar: nothog — "thou wilt be"
notha- + -g → nothog
The familiar second-person singular suffix -g appears in Tolkien's 1962 Sindarin paradigm (PE17/132).
Compare the present-tense forms gala ("he/she grows") and galog ("thou growest"), where the personal ending accompanies the change a → o.
Applying the same formation to our future stem gives nothog.
Status: Plausibly reconstructed Neo-Sindarin form based on the attested familiar ending and the Sindarin a/o alternation.
Second-person singular polite: nothol — "you will be"
notha- + -l → nothol
The polite second-person singular ending -l is documented in Tolkien's later Sindarin material (PE22/167).
Tolkien also supplies linnathol? ("will you sing?"), illustrating the ending in a future formation.
The preceding future vowel appears as o. Applying the same pattern gives nothol.
Status: Plausibly reconstructed Neo-Sindarin form, supported by the attested future linnathol.
Second-person singular archaic: nothodh — "you will be"
notha- + -dh → nothodh
Tolkien's 1962 paradigm uses the polite second-person singular suffix -ð, written -dh (PE17/132).
Strack suggests that this ending originated in -d(e) and may reflect an older or Doriathrin form of the polite second person, subsequently replaced by -l in later Sindarin.
Applying the ordinary singular a → o alternation gives nothodh.
This form is retained as an archaic or dialectal alternative to nothol, following our present- and past-tense paradigms.
Status: Plausibly reconstructed archaic-style Neo-Sindarin form. The Doriathrin association is tentative.
Second-person plural familiar: nothogir — "you will be"
The familiar plural suffix is -gir, corresponding to singular -g.
Two possible formations need distinguishing.
Analogical formation:
nothog + -ir → nothogir
This extends the fully formed singular conjugation with plural -ir, maintaining the same singular stem vowel o.
Historically conservative alternative:
notha- + -gir → nothagir
In Tolkien's 1962 paradigm, singular galog corresponds to plural galagir, not galogir (PE17/132). This provides direct evidence that the vowel a could remain before the complete plural suffix -gir.
Thus nothagir arguably follows the older attested vowel pattern more closely, whereas nothogir represents a regularisation based on the singular.
Status: Both forms are hypothetical Neo-Sindarin. The choice between them requires a decision on whether to preserve the historical vowel alternation or regularise the singular–plural relationship.
Second-person plural polite: notholir — "you will be"
nothol + -ir → notholir
The proposed polite plural follows the later singular suffix -l with the plural element -ir.
Although -l is attested in Tolkien's 1969 material, the complete later polite plural ending -lir is not directly attested.
Consequently, notholir is an analogical formation, corresponding to the proposed present naulir and past nílir.
The vowel o is retained from the singular nothol. No separate historical derivation establishes this exact plural vowel.
Status: Analogical Neo-Sindarin reconstruction.
Second-person plural archaic: nothodhir — "you will be"
The archaic polite second-person plural ending -dhir is attested in Tolkien's 1962 paradigm (PE17/132).
Again, two formations are possible.
Analogical formation:
nothodh + -ir → nothodhir
This preserves the o of the singular form.
Historically conservative alternative:
notha- + -dhir → nothadhir
Tolkien's 1962 paradigm has galaðir, with a preceding the polite plural suffix, rather than a form with o.
Therefore, nothadhir better reproduces that attested pattern, while nothodhir regularises the relationship with singular nothodh.
Both remain hypothetical copular conjugations.
Status: Plausibly reconstructed Neo-Sindarin alternatives, with nothadhir enjoying the closer historical analogy.
Third-person singular: notha — "he/she/it will be"
nātʰā → notha
The third-person singular takes no pronominal suffix.
The form is the proposed regular Sindarin development of primitive nā- combined with the Old Noldorin future suffix -thā, retaining the grammatical future ending -a.
Tolkien's attested future forms anglennatha (SD/129) and galatha (as reconstructed from the Sindarin paradigm) demonstrate the general pattern of an uninflected future ending in -a.
Tolkien also experimented with natho, subsequently replaced by thor, in the Túrin Wrapper (VT50/23). Those forms are not equivalent to an attested notha, and their interpretation remains uncertain.
Status: Plausibly derived Neo-Sindarin reconstruction, not attested.
Third-person plural: nothar — "they will be"
notha- + -r → nothar
The third-person plural is formed by adding the Sindarin plural agreement ending -r.
Unlike most singular personal suffixes, -r ordinarily leaves the preceding future vowel as a.
Compare Tolkien's estathar (SD/129) and the 1962 present-tense contrast gala : galar (PE17/132).
This gives nothar, rather than nothor.
Status: Plausibly reconstructed Neo-Sindarin form, closely following attested verbal agreement and vowel patterns.
Summary
| Person | Future tense |
|---|---|
| First singular | nothon |
| First plural exclusive | nothof |
| First plural inclusive | nothab |
| Second singular familiar | nothog |
| Second singular polite | nothol |
| Second singular archaic | nothodh |
| Second plural familiar | nothogir (alternatively nothagir) |
| Second plural polite | notholir |
| Second plural archaic | nothodhir (alternatively nothadhir) |
| Third singular | notha |
| Third plural | nothar |
All eleven conjugations are unattested Neo-Sindarin reconstructions. The principal uncertainties concern the precise historical formation of the future copular stem, the retention of final -a, and whether the second-person plural forms should preserve Tolkien's older a/o alternation or undergo analogical regularisation.
Historical and semantic qualifications
The reconstruction uses the Old Noldorin future suffix -thā, discussed in PE22/96–97 and PE22/131, as the historical basis for a general future tense.
In Tolkien's later Sindarin notes (PE22/165–168), the suffix -(a)tha was instead associated with willingness or intention. For an intention-neutral future, Tolkien proposed an auxiliary construction involving tol- ("come").
The proposed Neo-Sindarin paradigm standardises the future suffix for general future reference, following common Neo-Sindarin practice. This is an editorial reconstruction rather than a claim that Tolkien's successive explanations of the suffix were identical.
The alternative future copula tho(r), associated with the Túrin Wrapper, is retained as historical evidence of another possible analysis, but is not incorporated into the present paradigm.
Principal sources
- Tolkien, Parma Eldalamberon 22, pp. 96–97 — Old Noldorin future -thā
- Tolkien, Parma Eldalamberon 22, p. 131 — Primitive Sindarin future formations
- Tolkien, Parma Eldalamberon 17, p. 132 — Sindarin pronominal paradigms
- Tolkien, Parma Eldalamberon 22, pp. 165–168 — Later Sindarin volitional future and pronominal inflections
- Tolkien, Vinyar Tengwar 50, p. 23 — natho → thor
- Tolkien, Sauron Defeated, p. 129 — anglennatha, estathar
- Tolkien, The Lord of the Rings, Book II, Chapter 8 — linnathon
- Eldamo: Sindarin future
- Eldamo: Sindarin verb inflections
- Eldamo: Sindarin subject suffixes
- Eldamo: natha- "to bring help to, save, rescue"
Non-finite forms and imperative
The following forms extend the reconstructed paradigm of Sindarin na- ("to be"), based on Primitive Eldarin √NA/√NĀ (PE17/93; PE22/147; VT49/27–31).
Unlike the indicative conjugations, these forms rely on ancient participial and nominal suffixes, some of which require irregular application to the monosyllabic, vowel-final stem. Except for the imperative no, none is directly attested as a Sindarin form of na-.
Present active participle: nâl — "being"
Primitive Eldarin possessed an active participial suffix ✶-lā (PE22/136). The ordinary Sindarin continuative participle -ol probably developed from the continuative marker ✶-ā- combined with ✶-lā:
✶-āla → -ǭl(a) → -ol
This formation is discussed by Paul Strack in his analysis of Sindarin active participles, with Tolkien's úgarol (PE17/144) providing direct evidence for the continuative suffix.
For na-, however, the use of ✶-ā- creates a difficulty. Applying ✶-lā to a stem containing long ā would produce ✶nālā, whose expected Sindarin development is approximately:
✶nālā → nāla → nǭla → naul
The survival of au is supported by the development of stressed long ā in monosyllables, including ✶kānā > S. caun (PM/362).
This would produce a homonym of our reconstructed second-person singular polite present, naul ("you are").
To distinguish the two functions, we instead propose a direct active-participial formation from the short-vowel variant √NA:
√NA + ✶-lā → ✶nalā → nala → nal → nâl
The development involves shortening of final long ā, loss of the resulting final short vowel, and lengthening of the stressed vowel in the resulting monosyllable before l.
The morphological justification is that √NA/√NĀ is inherently stative. We hypothesise that such a verb could form an active participle directly with ✶-lā, without first adding a distinct continuative marker.
Status: Hypothetical Neo-Sindarin reconstruction. The sound changes are supported, but omission of the continuative marker is not explicitly attested for this verb. The choice also avoids homonymy with naul, although this practical advantage is not itself historical evidence.
Sources:
- PE22/136
- PE17/144
- PM/362
- Eldamo: ✶-lā
- Monosyllabic vowel lengthening
Past active participle: unresolved — "having been"
Sindarin distinguishes the present active participle from a past or perfective active participle expressing an action completed before another event.
The distinction is illustrated by Tolkien's diriel ("gazing") and díriel ("having gazed"), discussed in RGEO/64–65. The past active participle normally involves the ancient perfect stem and the active participial suffix, ultimately producing the Sindarin ending -iel.
For √NA/√NĀ, however, we have not established an equivalent past or perfect participial stem.
Our indicative past reconstruction uses Primitive Eldarin ✶nē, an independently recorded past element meaning "was" (PE22/96–97; VT49/28–30).
One possibility would be to investigate the attachment of ✶-lā to this past element:
✶nē + ✶-lā → ✶nēlā
The resulting hypothetical Sindarin nîl would collide with our reconstructed second-person singular polite past tense of the same spelling. More importantly, we have not established that this construction follows Tolkien's mature system of Sindarin perfective participles.
We previously considered noel, potentially derived from ✶nāljā. However, the existence of an active participial formation does not by itself establish past or perfective meaning. The tense must be justified through the underlying verbal stem or an independently documented morphological distinction.
Quenya anaië ("has been"), associated with √NĀ, provides evidence that Tolkien contemplated a perfect form of this verb, but does not establish its Sindarin participial descendant.
Status: Unresolved. No past active participle is adopted at present. Both nîl and noel require further historical and morphological justification.
Sources:
- PE17/7, 25, 82
- PE22/96–97, 108, 136, 155
- RGEO/64–65
- VT49/27–31
- Eldamo: Sindarin active participles
Past participle: nân — "been"
Primitive Eldarin possessed the adjectival and passive-participial suffixes ✶-nā and ✶-inā (PE17/131; PE22/136).
The longer suffix ✶-inā is found in formations such as ✶mantinā, the past passive participle of √MAT ("eat"). However, attaching it to our selected ancient past element ✶nē would yield ✶nēinā, introducing an uncertain encounter between long ē and short i.
The alternative suffix ✶-nā could be attached directly to a bare verbal stem. Tolkien also allowed such adjectival formations with intransitive verbs, so their historical function need not always have been strictly passive.
We therefore propose an irregular adjectival participle formed directly from √NA:
√NA + ✶-nā → ✶nanā → nana → nan → nân
The development follows the regular shortening and loss of final vowels and the subsequent lengthening of the stressed vowel in a monosyllable ending in n.
This construction deliberately parallels our present active participle nâl, but employs an ancient adjectival/resultative suffix rather than an active one.
Semantic qualification: Since "to be" is ordinarily intransitive and stative, nân should not be regarded as an ordinary passive participle implying an external agent. It is proposed as a past or resultative adjectival participle, with "been" as its approximate English gloss.
This does not establish an auxiliary function for na-, nor does it authorise importing English perfect constructions into Sindarin.
Status: Hypothetical Neo-Sindarin reconstruction. The suffix and phonological development are supported, but its attachment to √NA and its precise resultative meaning remain speculative.
Sources:
- PE17/131
- PE22/106–108, 136
- Eldamo: ✶-nā
- Eldamo: ✶-inā
Imperative: no — "be!", "may it be!"
Unlike the preceding forms, the imperative no is directly attested in Tolkien's Sindarin translation of the Lord's Prayer:
no aer i eneth lín
"Hallowed be thy name" (VT44/21).
The meaning is approximately "be holy thy name", demonstrating the use of no to express a command or wish.
The ordinary Sindarin imperative employs the ending -o, ultimately associated with an ancient imperative particle ✶ā (PE22/139–140; WJ/365). The irregular verb na- nevertheless has its own directly attested imperative form, so its precise earlier phonological development need not be reconstructed to justify its use.
The imperative is therefore retained unchanged as no, irrespective of the speculative present, past and future conjugations proposed elsewhere.
There is insufficient evidence to establish separate plural imperatives such as nor or nogir. The Sindarin imperative in -o could serve independently of the number of people addressed.
Status: Attested Sindarin, VT44/21. The imperative is the most securely established verbal form in this reconstruction.
Sources:
- VT44/21–22
- PE22/139–140
- WJ/365
- Eldamo: Sindarin na-
Verbal noun: noed — "being", "to be"
In later Sindarin, the verbal noun commonly functions both as a gerund ("being") and as the infinitival object of another verb ("to be").
Tolkien identified the ancient Sindarin verbal-noun suffix as ✶-ita (PE17/68), reflected in formations such as cared ("doing", "to do") from car-.
Our reconstruction proposes applying this suffix to the long-vowel stem √NĀ:
✶nā + ✶-ita → ✶nāita
A possible subsequent development would involve the historical changes:
ā → ǭ, ǭi → oi → oe
Together with the development of medial t and the loss of the final vowel, these suggest the candidate:
✶nāita → noed
The arrow denotes a proposed development rather than a fully established historical sequence. In particular, the precise treatment of the vowel encounter ā+i in this formation requires further verification.
The previously considered nad is also a historically recorded noun meaning "thing", associated with √NĀ and primitive ✶nata (Ety/NĀ; VT49/30). However, its existence does not establish that it was a Sindarin gerund meaning "being".
Accordingly, noed is provisionally preferred as a distinct verbal noun, rather than assigning the new grammatical function to nad without evidence.
Status: Tentative Neo-Sindarin reconstruction. The ancient suffix is attested and its proposed application is morphologically plausible, but the complete phonological derivation and resulting Sindarin form are not directly attested.
Sources:
- PE17/68
- VT49/30
- Eldamo: Sindarin verbal nouns
- Development of ǭi
- Development of oi to oe
Summary
| Function | Proposed form | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Present active participle | nâl | Hypothetical, provisionally adopted |
| Past active participle | — | Unresolved |
| Past/resultative participle | nân | Hypothetical, provisionally adopted |
| Imperative | no | Attested |
| Verbal noun / gerund | noed | Tentative, requires further verification |
These proposals are intended to complete an internally coherent Neo-Sindarin paradigm rather than to reconstruct an unattested system with certainty. The two adjectival participles derive directly from √NA, while the verbal noun provisionally employs the longer √NĀ. The imperative retains Tolkien's attested form, and the past active participle remains open pending a better-supported derivation.
The full paradigm
Putting it all together, the reconstructed paradigm of na- ("to be") looks like this:
| Person | Present | Past | Future |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1st person I | naun | nîn | nothon |
| 2nd person thou | naug | nîg | nothog |
| 2nd person (polite) | naul | nîl | nothol |
| 2nd person (archaic) | naudh | nîdh | nothodh |
| 3rd person he/she/it | naw | nî | notha |
| 1st person we (exclusive) | nauf | nîf | nothof |
| 1st person we (inclusive) | naub | nîb | nothab |
| 2nd person you | naugir | nígir | nothogir |
| 2nd person (polite) | naulir | nílir | notholir |
| 2nd person (archaic) | naudhir | nídhir | nothodhir |
| 3rd person they | nar | nîr | nothar |
| Form | Sindarin | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| Verbal noun | noed | being / to be |
| Imperative | no (pl. nor / nogir) | be / may it be |
| Present active participle | nâl | being |
| Past active participle | noel | (provisory) |
| Past participle | nân | been |